Want to be like a celebrity makeup artist? Want to look like Lady Gaga? For woman's who want perfect and flawless makeup, having the best quality gel eyeliner is a must. It comes in various formulas that can create any eye looks you want, from a bold and dramatic cat eye to a soft and smoky look.

However, not all can deliver the desired result, so choosing one that suits your needs and preferences is important. Looking for the best gel eyeliner to create any look you want? If so, we've got you covered.

With so many choices on the market, finding which one fits you politely can take time and effort. That's why we've created a list of the top 4 best gel eyeliners that are perfect and safe for you no matter what look you're looking for.

Click here to find out everything about the top 4 best gel eyeliners!

We have searched for the best, so you don't have to live with the rest. In order to serve you to the best of our ability and to keep our blog going, GarnesGuide may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page if you decide to buy. Each product was independently researched by our editors, and the reviews may have been edited for length and clarity.

How We Choose The Best Gel Eyeliner:

Mastering the art of eyeliner is integral to any impeccable makeup look, yet the quest for the perfect formula can be quite a challenge. Not all gel eyeliners are crafted alike; each formula brings its unique strengths, catering to various preferences and styles. Some are expertly formulated for bold and dramatic looks, while others excel in achieving a soft and smokey eye effect.

Our dedicated research has unveiled the top 4 gel eyeliners reigning supreme in the market. Whether your preference leans towards a classic black liner for a timeless look or something more vibrant to add a splash of color and intrigue, we've got you covered.

Navigate through our insightful guide to discover the ideal gel eyeliners that align with your desired makeup aesthetics. Elevate your eyeliner game with the confidence that comes from using one of the best products the market has to offer.

Best Eyeliner For Bold Cat-Eye or Sultry Smokey Look


Check Price on Amazon

Why GG Loves It

Looking to add some drama to your hooded eyes? If so, then check out the NYX Professional Makeup's Gel Liner. It is the perfect way to create a bold cat-eye or smoky look that will really make your eyes stand out in front of the crowd. Similar to liquid liner or mechanical pencil liner, its highly pigmented formula helps you to get a better result.

This long-wearing, waterproof eyeliner glides on smoothly and dries quickly, giving you the beautiful and silky texture that will last all day, similar to bobbi brown gel eyeliner. Its precision brush tip makes applying the perfect amount of liner easy, so you can create any look you desire. Its long-wear formula contain intensely pigmented shades that will give you need look every day.

This gel eyeliner pot is also available in natural shades, which means you can go as bold or as subtle as you want. In reality, with its gel-based formula and smudge-proof resistance, you can give a complete and compelling look that will last you throughout the day. It is the best gel eyeliner if you're looking for solution that will really make your eyes pop.

What You Should Know

NYX cosmetics gel eyeliner or other products like concealers, eye shadow palettes, setting sprays, fake lashes, lipstick, or mascara are 100% cruelty-free because they believe that all animals belong to our arms, not in products.

They dont test any of their products on animals, and all of their makeup is acknowledged and certified by PETA. For those who are looking for lasting drama gel eyeliner, then this is the best solution to go with.

So whether you're headed to a special event or want to add a little drama to your everyday look, NYX Professional Makeup's Gel Liner is a perfect choice for you to compare to other waterproof gel eyeliners on the market.

Best Eyeliner For Daily Eyeliner or Eyebrow Makeup

UCANBE 2 in 1 Black and Brown Gel Eyeliner Set

Check Price on Amazon

Why GG Loves It

Are you looking for a gel eyeliner that will give you a perfect look for any occasion with its precise line? If so, then UCANBE has the perfect solution for you. With its classic colors, Black and Brown, you can achieve any look on any skin tone you want. With its creamy formula, you can create a smooth lash line with a more natural look.

This waterproof gel eyeliner assures you a long-lasting makeup that can last for the whole day. It is also smudge-proof and easy to remove with remover. Its intense color will surely give you a dramatic look that will turn heads. Compare to kohl gel eyeliner that works perfectly on any skin tone and oily skin.

You can easily create an upper lash line with its intense color payoff range without worrying about it fading or creasing. Its formula is also ophthalmologist-tested and safe for contact lens wearers and sensitive eyes.

What You Should Know

The UCANBE 2-in-1 Black and Brown Gel Eyeliner Set is a great way to get perfect, natural-looking eyeliner every time. The set comes with two small eye makeup brushes, one angel liner brush, and another regular liner brush, so you can create any look you want.

The regular liner brush is great for creating a basic line, while the angle liner brush is perfect for creating a winged look. With these two brushes, you can easily create any eyeliner look you want. The gel formula is super easy to apply, and 24-hour gel eyeliner lasts all day, so you don't have to worry about spreading or blotching.

With this, you can easily achieve the perfect cat eye or winged look. Whether you're a beginner or a pro makeup artist, the UCANBE 2-in-1 Black and Brown Gel Eyeliner Set is a great way to get flawless eyeliner or eyebrows every time.

Best Eyeliner For Creating Any Look

Maybelline New York TattooStudio Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil

Check Price on Amazon

Why GG Loves It

If you're looking for an eyeliner that can create any look, then the Maybelline New York TattooStudio Waterproof Gel liner Pencil is a perfect choice. It is the world's number 1 makeup brand that offers everything from foundation to mascara to lipstick. With this waterproof eyeliner, you don't need any help from makeup artists.

This matte drugstore gel eyeliner pencil has a not only is it water resistant, it has waterproof formula that lasts up to 36 hours, so you can rest assured that your makeup will look flawless all day long. This sharpenable and long-wearing eyeliner is easy to apply and provides incredibly pigmented-loaded color and precise definition that glides on smoothly and evenly.

With this, you can easily find awesome shades for your every mood, from classic black to bright white. Whether you want to create a dramatic cat eye or go for a more dramatic look, this gel eyeliner pencil will help you achieve the perfect result. This will give you a more unique and ultra-smooth result than liquid eyeliner or drugstore eyeliner.

What You Should Know

Maybelline New York's TattooStudio Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil is extremely smudged and sweat resistant, making it the perfect product for those who want a long-lasting, defined look. The amazing thing about this long-wear gel eyeliner is that you can choose 13 different shades, and they all come with fading and sebum resistance.

The waterproof and smudge-proof formulas ensure that your makeup will not run or blotch, even if you sweat or get caught in the rain. Whether looking for a natural or a more dramatic look, this eyeliner pencil will help you create the perfect gaze. This is also one of the best gel eyeliners that are perfect for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers looking for something more than water resistant formulas.

Best Gel Eyeliner For Creating a Stylish look

Gel Eyeliner by Almay

Check Price on Amazon

Why GG Loves It

Gel eyeliner is a must-have in any makeup bag. It's perfect for creating various looks, from a natural daytime look to a sultry evening look. And with Almay's Gel Eyeliner, you can be sure you're getting the best of the best as done marc jacobs beauty.

This gel eyeliner glides on smoothly, providing rich, intense color that lasts all day long, as you get with liquid liner. Its pigmented formula is waterproof and smudge-proof, so you'll never have to worry about your eyeliner fading or smudging.

And it comes in a range of stunning shades, from shimmer shades to classic black to more adventurous colors like teal and purple. So if you're looking for an eyeliner that will give you a gorgeous and smooth texture and long-lasting results, then Almay's Gel Eyeliner is perfect.

What You Should Know

For sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, it is essential to use the right gel liner; if not, then it can lead to severe eye or skin problems. But Almay's Gel Eyeliner is formulated without any harmful substances like DMDM Hydantoin, Triclosan, formaldehyde, mineral oil, titanium dioxide, SLS, parabens, and phthalates.

This eyeliner is made from 85% recycled paper and is EWG verified, which means it is 100% safe and secure to use. The long-wearing formula is also ideal for those with allergies or sensitivities, as it does not contain any fragrances or irritants.

With this, you will get a creamy texture color that looks just like other liquid eyeliners or mac cosmetics without any side effects. Whether looking for a natural or bold look, Almay's gel eyeliner is a great option to help you achieve the perfect stare.

Here are Some FAQs to Help Guide you on Your Way!

Gel eyeliner can be difficult to apply, and it's easy to end up with a mess on your face. Applying gel eyeliner can be challenging, especially if you're new to the game. The process can seem daunting if this is your first time using this type of liner.

Don't worry; we're here to help! Our FAQ section covers everything from how to apply gel eyeliner for beginners to troubleshooting common problems, so read on to find your specific or common concern related to it.

best eyeliner for waterline

How to apply gel eyeliner?

It can be tricky to apply gel liner at first, but with a little bit of practice, it's really not that hard. Here are a few tips:

1. From the inside to the outside corner of your eye, begin by drawing a thin line along your top lash line.

2. Go back and fill in the line, thickening it as you go.

3. Use a brush or your fingers to smudge the liner into your lashes for a soft look.

4. For extra staying power, finish with a coat of mascara.

best waterproof eyeliner

How to use gel eyeliner?

There are different ways to use gel eyeliner, but applying it with an angled brush is the most common. You can start by drawing the line at the inner corner of your eye and then working towards the outer corner. You can also add a thicker line on the top lid for a more dramatic look. If you're having trouble getting the liner to stay on, you can try using a primer first. And be sure to keep your mechanical pencil liner sharpened so they'll be easy to use.

How to sharpen gel eyeliner pencil?

There are multiple ways to sharpen gel eyeliner pencils. You can use a sharpener specifically designed for them or a regular sharpener if you're careful:

  1. Cut off the pencil's tip, so there's about 1/4 inch of lead left.
  2. Twist the pencil so that the lead is at the top. Now, hold the pencil horizontally and insert it into the sharpener (so that the lead is facing down).
  3. Remove the pencil and brush away any excess lead residue with a brush or your fingers.

How to remove eyeliner?

It depends on what kind of eyeliner you are using. If it is a pencil eyeliner, then you can use a makeup remover or oil to take it off. If it is a liquid eyeliner, then you can utilize a cotton ball or pad soaked in remover to take it off. Hope this helps!


What color eyeliner for blue eyes?

There are so many great options for good eyeliner colors to enhance blue eyes! You can go with a cool black, espresso brown, rose gold, or even navy. A light shimmery color like champagne or gold can also make your eyes look brighter and more radiant. Experiment until you find the color that brings out the most flattering aspect of your blue eyes and something that fits your skin tone! Contact a pro makeup artist if you need help finding the right one.

How to remove magnetic eyeliner?

Magnetic eyeliner is just like any other type of liner - it can be removed with makeup remover or soap and water. Be sure to use a gentle motion when removing it, as the magnet can be a little rough on the delicate skin type and any skin tone around your eyes. Also, make sure to avoid mineral oil, titanium dioxide, if you want to make your eyes pop again.

Can you wear eyeliner with lash extensions?

Yes! You can definitely wear eyeliner with lash extensions. Just be sure to use a waterproof long-wearing formula, even the ones with vitamin E, so your liner doesn't smudge or run. Also, avoid using any oil-based makeup remover, as it can weaken the adhesive that holds your lashes in place. A mild soap and water should be enough to clean up any liner or humidity-resistant wear mistakes.

How to use eyeshadow as eyeliner?

There are numerous ways to do this. The first is to use an angled brush to apply the eyeshadow in a thin line close to your lash line. You can also use a dampened or professional brush for more intense color. Another option is to apply eyeliner over top of the eyeshadow, which will help it last longer. Finally, you can use a darker eyeshadow as an eyeliner by dusting it on with a fluffy brush and then blending well.

best eyeliners

Top 4 Best Gel Eyeliners:

For any woman who wants to achieve the most attractive look, eyeliner is one of the most important fortes in their makeup kit. Here we've highlighted four of the best gel eyeliners and examined what makes them great choices for you to achieve the desired look of your choice.

Whether you wanna go out to a party or on vacation, these best eyeliners have covered you with their highly pigmented shades, precise lines, and smudge-proof formula so you can achieve what you deserve and dream.

We hope this information has helped you decide which type of eyeliner will work best.

Read our article about best hypoallergenic eyeliner here!

Read our article about best makeup brush cleaner here!

Read our article about best tattoo numbing cream here!

Read our article about drugstore eyebrow gel here!

Read our article about best primer for acne prone skin here!