Why Drugstore Eyeliners are the Unsung Heroes of the Beauty Aisle

Ah, the beauty aisle. A place where dreams come true and bank accounts, well... shiver. But if you're ducking and diving, evading those overpriced mascaras, let's pause a sec. Nestled among the glitter and glam are the unsung heroes: drugstore eyeliners. These babies pack a punch without knocking out your wallet!

Dive into the world of affordable, quality eyeliners:
Everyone loves a good bargain, especially when that bargain is an eyeliner that rivals its high-end counterpart. Drugstore eyeliners have been stepping up their game, delivering bold and consistent lines that won't smudge, no matter how many tear-jerker movies you watch.

Why price doesn't always equate to quality:
Let's debunk a myth, shall we? Expensive doesn’t always mean better. Many drugstore brands have been in the beauty biz for decades, perfecting their formulas. So, while your wallet feels heavier, your eyelids won't!

black drugstore eyeliner

Unraveling the Mystery: Types of Eyeliners

Much like the complex world of dating apps, eyeliners come in all shapes and sizes. Let's swipe right on understanding these types a bit more, shall we?

Pencil Eyeliners

Pros and cons of the classic choice:
The OG of eyeliners! Perfect for beginners, they're forgiving and easy to use. Want a sultry smudged look? It’s your bestie. But beware! Cheap ones can tug at your lids, so pick a smooth operator.

Tips for a smudge-free application:
Freeze your pencil liner for 10 minutes before applying. This firms up the tip, making it less likely to smudge. And remember, tightlining is your friend! Get in between those lashes for a fuller look.

Gel and Cream Eyeliners

The scoop on their creamy texture and vibrant hues:
Imagine your eyeliner had a baby with a pot of cream. Voilà! It's rich, velvety, and slides on like a dream. Plus, they come in a spectrum of popping shades. Electric blue cat-eye, anyone?

Mastering the art of the perfect wing with gel:
It's all about the brush! Opt for an angled one, and always, always clean it post-application. Start with small strokes, and remember: your wing should point toward the end of your eyebrow. Fly high, beauty queens!

Liquid Eyeliners

Dishing out on precision and that ultra-fine line:
Precision is the name of the game. With a sleek brush tip, liquid liners can give you a line so sharp, it could...well, let's just say your ex will regret ever ghosting you.

Quick-dry vs. regular: Which is best for you?
Quick-dry is for the pros — those who can sketch a masterpiece in seconds. But if you're someone who needs a moment (or five) to adjust and perfect, stick with the regular. Either way, ensure it's waterproof for those unexpected emotional (or rainy) days.

Our list of the top products in this category

1. NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Epic Ink Liner, Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner - Black

2. Wet n Wild MegaLiner Liquid Eyeliner

3. Revlon So Fierce Vinyl Eyeliner

4. Covergirl Ink It Perfect Point Plus Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil

5. Maybelline New York Hyper Easy Brush Tip Liquid Eyeliner

portrait of a brunette woman smiling

Ah, the drugstore makeup aisle, where one can easily get lost amidst a sea of liners promising the moon and stars. But fear not! I've got your back. Here's your trusty guide to decoding the essentials when it comes to picking the perfect eyeliner.

Longevity and Staying Power

There's smudged eyeliner... and then there's “Did I just star in a melodramatic music video?” eyeliner. Unless you're intentionally going for the latter (no judgment), you'll want an eyeliner that stays put. Look for terms like "waterproof," "smudge-proof," or "24-hour wear." And if it can survive that rom-com marathon tearfest? That's a keeper.

Pigmentation: Go Bold or Go Home!

Let's be real; nobody has time for an eyeliner that requires three layers to be visible. If you're craving that dramatic wing or a subtle lash line, a liner's pigmentation is key. The rule of thumb? The blacker (or bolder) the better. A single swipe should leave a solid, defined line. Bonus points if it makes your eyes pop like you're the main character in a novel.

Ingredients to Applaud and Avoid

Your eyes are the windows to your soul and, let's be real, they've seen some things (like that questionable text you sent at 2 AM). So, treat them right! Here's a quick breakdown:

  • Ophthalmologist-tested: This means an eye doctor has given it the green light for safety. Ideal for sensitive eyes.
  • Paraben-free: Parabens are often used as preservatives, but there's a bit of side-eye concerning their safety. Best to avoid if you can.
  • Vegan and Cruelty-free: No animal-derived ingredients and no animal testing. Bunnies everywhere rejoice!

Lastly, if your eyes tend to be sensitive, give a wide berth to liners with fragrances or alcohol. Your peepers will thank you.

black drugstore eyeliner against the red background

Eyes on the Prize: Application and Removal Tips

Achieving the Perfect Flick

Step-by-step to the cat-eye of your dreams:

  1. Steady Hands, Steady Heart: Start with a primed, oil-free lid. Pro-tip: Resting your elbow on a table can help stabilize your hand. Who knew?
  2. Close Encounters: Beginning at the inner corner, draw as close to the lash line as possible. It's like you're tickling your lashes.
  3. Angle It Right: When you hit the outer corner, aim towards the end of your brow. This angle will give you that chic, upward flick.
  4. Connect the Dots: Create a small line from the outermost point of the flick, back to your lash line. Fill it in and voilà!
  5. Oopsie Daisy: Made a mistake? It's okay; we all have our days. Use a damp Q-tip to clean up any rogue marks.
woman applying black eyeliner on her lower lash line in front of a mirror

Caring for those Peepers

Gentle removal techniques and aftercare:
After a day of serving fierce looks, it's time to treat those eyes with tender loving care.

  • Oil it Up: Oil-based removers or good ol' coconut oil can be your best bet. Gently massage over the eyelids, watch the liner melt away, and relish the magic.
  • Be Gentle, Darling: Use soft, circular motions to remove. Tugging? That's so last season.
  • Moisturize: Apply a gentle eye cream post-cleanup. Your under-eyes will feel like they just had a spa day.
beautiful curly woman smiling outdoors

Wrapping Up: Let Your Eyes Do the Talking!

And there we have it! A whirlwind journey through the enchanting aisles of drugstore eyeliners. Whether you're gunning for that sultry smokey eye or a subtle everyday look, there's a liner out there with your name on it (well, metaphorically speaking).

Remember, makeup is all about expressing yourself. So, go forth, experiment, and let the world see those dazzling eyes. Ready to redefine your signature style? Eyeliner first, world conquest next.